Donegal Group, Inc. (NASDAQ:DGICA)
Q1 2017 Results Earnings Conference Call
April 19, 2017, 11:00 AM ET
Jeff Miller – CFO
Kevin Burke – President and CEO
Don Nikolaus – Chairman
Christopher Campbell – KBW
Jamie Inglis – PhiloSmith
Good morning. My name is Matthew and I will be your conference operator today. At this time, I would like to welcome everyone to the Donegal Group Q1 2017 Earnings Conference Call. [Operator Instructions] Thank you.
Jeff Miller, you may begin your conference.
Thank you very much. Good morning and welcome to the Donegal Group conference call for the first quarter ended March 31, 2017. I’m Jeff Miller, Chief Financial Officer and I will begin today’s call with commentary on our quarterly financial results. Kevin Burke, President and Chief Executive Officer will then discuss our current business developments and growth initiatives. Following that, our Chairman Don Nikolaus will share his perspective on our ongoing business strategy before we open the line for questions.
You should be aware that certain statements made in our news release and in this conference call are forward-looking in nature and involve a number of risks and uncertainties. Please refer to our news release for more information about forward-looking statements. Further information on risk factors that could cause actual results to differ materially from those projected in the forward-looking statements is available in the report on Form 10-K that we submitted to the SEC.
You can find a copy of our Form 10-K in the Investors section of our website under the SEC Filings link. Further, reconciliation of non-GAAP information as required by SEC Regulation G, was provided in our news release which is also available in the Investors section of our website.
With that let’s discuss Donegal Group’s operating results. Our first quarter was highlighted by strong premium growth across our lines of business and solid profitability despite a higher frequency of weather-related claims during the period. We achieved an 8.5% increase in our net premiums written to $184.5 million during the quarter with 9.6% growth in our commercial lines and 7.4% growth in our personal lines.
The growth rate would have been higher during the period but it was somewhat constrained by reinsurance reinstatement premiums that reduced net premiums written for our homeowners line of business and our commercial multi-peril line of business by 4.5% and 2.5% respectively.
We’ve been pleased with our growth trends specifically in our commercial business segment as we continue to reap benefits from our long-standing relationships with our agents and our efforts to balance our product mix. During the first quarter, our commercial lines writing eclipsed our personal lines writings. We attribute that occurrence and part to the fact that a large segment of commercial policies renew on January 1 but it also reflects a greater emphasis we have placed on growing our commercial lines over the past few years.
Turning to the bottom line for the first quarter 2017, Donegal Group reported net income of $5.1 million or $0.18 per diluted Class A share compared to $11.8 million or $0.46 per diluted Class A share for the first quarter 2016. Our statutory combined ratio for the first quarter of 2017 was 99.6% compared to 92.1% for the prior year period.
Our underwriting performance for the quarter was solid overall but it did include higher-than-expected weather-related losses and a continued impact of higher loss activity in personal and commercial auto. Our workers compensation line of business continued to perform exceptionally well with an 80.8% statutory combined ratio for the first quarter. This performance was a continuation of a favorable trend over multiple periods of lower claims frequency in this line.
Underwriting results for our homeowners and commercial multi-peril lines of business were adversely impacted by weather-related losses during the first quarter of 2017 primarily attributable to numerous wind and hail events in our Mid-Atlantic Midwestern and Southern region.
To provide some additional details, in January we were impacted by significant storm activity throughout the South including Tornado event in Georgia. In late February, we incurred claims from storms throughout the Mid-Atlantic that included high winds and hail and then we experienced the number of wind storm events in several regions during the month of March.
None of these storm events caused insured losses that exceeded our $5 million external catastrophe reinsurance retention amount. However, the cumulative impact of numerous smaller storm systems was far greater than our historical first quarter average for weather-related losses.
Intercompany catastrophe reinsurance with Donegal Mutual Insurance Company limited the financial impact of losses from two of the wind and hail events during the first quarter of 2017 but those intercompany loss recoveries triggered offsetting reinsurance reinstatement premiums of $2 million.
For the first quarter of 2017 our statutory loss ratio increased to 67.9% compared to 60.2% for the first quarter of 2016. Weather-related losses of $14.3 million for the first quarter of 2017 or 8.4 percentage points of our loss ratio increase from the $6.9 million or 4.4 percentage points of our loss ratio reported in the prior period.
For comparison, our five year average for first quarter weather-related losses was $8.3 million. As we discussed in the past, weather loss activity is a normal part of our business and while we would obviously prefer not to incur weather-related losses, we generally benefit from the service opportunities these events provide for us to fulfill our promise, to be there when it matters most in support of our independent agents and our policyholders.
Large fire losses which we define as individual fire losses in excess of $50,000 were consistent with the prior-year first quarter. Over the first quarter 2017, these losses were $5.9 million or 3.5 percentage points of our loss ratio compared to $5.8 million or 3.7 percentage points of our loss ratio for the prior year period.
On the expense side, our statutory expense ratio was 31.1% for the first quarter of 2017 compared to 31.3% for the first quarter of 2016. The modest decrease in our statutory expense ratio reflected lower underwriting based incentive costs for the first quarter of 2017.
Turning briefly to the investment portfolio, our net investment income increased 3.8% for the first quarter primarily related to an increase in average invested assets relative to the prior-year first quarter. Our book value per share increased to $16.43 at March 31, 2017 compared to $16.21 at year-end 2016.
At this point, I’ll turn the call over to Kevin for his comments on the quarter.
Thank you, Jeff.
Overall we were pleased with the continued strong organic growth throughout all of our lines of business despite the weather activity that Jeff highlighted. The first quarter demonstrates our commitment and ability to continue to gain market share and grow within our existing agency base. We have built a culture focused on executing a strategy that leverages our strengths as a regional carrier to outperform over the long-term. We’re committed to producing favorable underwriting results in pursuing including growth as we work closely with our independent agents.
Our premium growth in the recent years have been remarkably consistent. From 2014 to 2015 Donegal grew net written premiums at approximately 8.5%. From 2015 to 2016 we also grew at approximately 8.5% and in the first quarter of 2017 net written premiums once again grew at 8.5%.
We are pleased that we are growing consistently and more importantly we believe that we’re growing the right way. We have continue to gain market share over many of our competitors by being highly responsive to our policyholders and agents, and providing a competitive array of personal commercial lines products.
We‘ve had excellent results in our workers compensation and commercial multi-peril lines with premium growth in the high single digits, along with favorable loss ratios. We have turned our focus to the personal and commercial automobile lines of business where we have begun to experience higher than expected loss ratios over the past few periods.
Our peers throughout the property and casualty industry have noted similar or even more extreme trends and many have outlined reasons such as increased effects of distracted driving, the higher cost of repairs due to technology features in today’s vehicles, and an increase number of miles driven due to improvement in economic conditions. As part of our profit improvement plan we’re taking the following steps.
First, we start by working closely with our independent agents to further understand the dynamics of our regional markets. Within our agency network there are a large number of agents that have increased their commitment to us and have generated consistent profitable underwriting results for our companies. In many cases these are agents with whom we’ve had relationship with for decades and they provide excellent market feedback that helps us to remain competitive in our pricing and coverage options.
Many of these agents are also stockholders of our company further aligning their interest in promoting our long-term success. Feedback from our agents is critical as we consider rate increases and determine what specific tools would best be suited for evaluating risk in achieving rate adequacy.
We have implemented and will continue to file rate increases where appropriate with auto rate filings typically increasing the mid-single digits range depending upon the state and subsidiary. Market conditions support increased automobile pricing and we understand that we’ve arrived at a point where Donegal Group can use its competitive advantages and strong agency relationships to differentiate itself from other carriers.
In addition to rate increases, we been evaluating what additional tools would be effective in utilizing technology to its utmost potential. We will soon began to implement our commercial auto predictive model for new business in several states which specifically identifies predictive factors that correlate the higher loss ratios. This will be another tool available for Donegal to refine its underwriting criteria and pricing.
We employed a similar predictive model for personal auto and we are evaluating ways to further leverage that model, as well as ways to utilize telematic devices and the data those devices provide.
While we implement those measures over time through ongoing initiatives, we expect the combined effort of improved rate adequacy and underwriting refinement will begin to show tangible results in our auto lines of business throughout the remainder of 2017. For the first quarter, policy retention levels in both personal lines and commercial lines remain very strong despite the competitive marketplace. In commercial lines we’re continuing to obtain modest renewal increases with increased pressure on some larger accounts.
Turning to our marketing efforts, we have completed over 20 spring agency sales meeting since January and we are pleased to report that we had excellent attendance at each of these meetings. Our agency sales meetings vary in size from 50 to 180 agents attending each of these meetings and it is one of our major marketing initiatives that we continue to conduct each year. We view these meetings as great opportunities to update our agents on product and technology enhancements, and an opportunity for our agents to interact with Donegal management, marketing and underwriting personnel.
Although many of our competitors have reduced or eliminated similar meetings, Donegal continues to conduct these meetings and our agents value and appreciate the accessibility they have to the Donegal management team.
In summary, we were pleased overall with our growth and profitability despite the weather impact in the first quarter and we continue to make progress executing on our long-term strategy. The conditions we are experiencing in many of our markets indicate that we can continue to deliver both solid premium growth and superior underwriting performance.
At this point I’ll turn the call over to Don Nikolaus for his comments before we open the lines for questions. Thank you.
Thank you, Kevin and Jeff. In many ways our performance in a period like the first quarter provides evidence that are more in line diversified strategy is an effective one. Especially as we deal with the challenges of a changing marketplace.
We were pleased to achieve solid growth in both personal and commercial lines. Despite the weather events and changing dynamics within the automobile line that Jeff and Kevin highlighted, we continue to report profitable results.
Our book value continued to increase during the period. At March 31, 2017 our book value per share increased to $16.43 compared to $16.21 at December 31, 2016. Our net income during the first quarter of 2017, as well as modest increase in unrealized gains within our investment portfolio contributed to the increase in our book value at March 31.
We are committed to our long-standing goal to generate underwriting results that outperform the insurance industry and that combined with solid investment returns will help deliver superior book value appreciation over time. Needless to say, the overall profitability levels in the first quarter were not where we would like them today, but we believe the fundamentals of our book of business are very solid and form the basis for much better profitability going forward.
At this point we would be glad to respond to questions that you may have.
[Operator Instructions] Your first question comes from the line of Christopher Campbell from KBW. Your line is open.
Hi, good morning. Quick question on the premium growth, which has been pretty strong. How much of this is coming from new agency appointments versus just your existing agency plan?
Chris, the majority of it is coming from the existing agency plan. First quarter we appointed 38 new agencies and that’s pretty consistent with what you would have seen last year at this time but what we’re seeing is really a ramp up with the existing agency base committing more and more business to Donegal.
So the majority of that growth has been really with the existing agency base, the agents that we have appointed over the last couple of years are absolutely committing additional business to us but it’s really the existing agency plan has been excellent for us.
Okay, great. And then just a second question on – I know, Donegal Mutual has – is the Mountain States acquisition as originally going to go through Donegal Mutual. Now as part of that Donegal Mutual is getting access to these independent agents out in Texas, Utah, Colorado and et cetera. Is there an opportunity for DGI to get to start distributing products through that independent agency network even before the results are pulled?
Chris, this is Jeff. At this point we’re not planning to introduce the other companies the subsidiaries of Donegal Group in those states. We may do that over time as we build out our marketing presence but the current concentration is to obviously finish the mergers that we’re getting close to that. We would hope that that’s going to happen within the next month that we would see Donegal Mutual be able to complete the merger.
And then there’s going to be a period of time where we bring our technology, our products, and do a complete assessment of the marketing plan to the agencies they’re representing Mountain States currently, building our marketing distribution system by appointing some additional agents in those states. And overtime, we would expect that some of the other companies may also become admitted in those states.
But currently the plan is that the Donegal Group will benefit through its participation in the pool but that won’t happen until we complete the rehabilitation process of the underwriting activities that are currently transpiring in those states. And we at this point don’t have a specific time frame in mind for that but it will be at least 18 months to two years before we are likely in a position to include that business in the pool between Donegal Mutual and Atlantic States.
Okay, great that was really helpful. And just a final housekeeping question. Lower taxes year-over-year, that was attributable to the lower underwriting income, correct? Is there anything else that…
No, that is correct we of course project out what we believe our annual taxable income will be and then calculate an effective tax rate and we would’ve done the same process in prior periods and the lower underwriting income is definitely impacting the projected tax rate.
Okay, great. Well thanks for all the answers and best of luck in 2Q.
[Operator Instructions] Your next question comes from the line Jamie Inglis with PhiloSmith. Your line is open.
Good morning, guys. Both Jeff and Kevin, you both talked about commercial auto and what’s going on and I’m wondering, what’s happening to that book of business? Meaning has the underlying characteristics with book changed and types of risks you’re writing, the geography that’s been written sort of what’s happening there?
Jamie, this is Kevin. First obviously the characteristics of the book of business has not changed. So there’s no trends that we’re saying that we have ventured into different classes of business or different geography that would be causing any issue there. There’s a couple of issues at play and these are really almost industry-wide.
From our perspective because we are account writers when we look at an overall commercial account, we will write the commercial auto and at sometimes it’s a little bit at a loss in terms of rate adequacy and so we’re working hard to make sure that from a rate perspective, we are taking some rate increases in commercial auto.
The other aspect of it too which you’re starting to see again cross industry is as the economy picks up, you are having frequency or having additional drivers on the road. In some areas of the business sector you’re having qualifications of those drivers, is it – are they running appropriate background checks on those drivers. From our perspective, our underwriting is still I think extremely well done and I think it’s partially rate adequacy and frequency and it’s those are two things that we are addressing.
And as I noted in my comments we are piloting a predictive analytics tool for commercial auto and we’re about to implement that in a couple of states and we’re hopeful that over the next couple of months will be able to analyze the results and with the intention of being able to roll that out through all the geographical areas where we write commercial auto.
Can I ask a follow-up question on the agency force. Are you – I’m trying to breakdown different stream, existing agents and new agents. Are your existing agents would you say larger and more diversified than your new agents?
No, I wouldn’t say that. The new agents that we appointed Jamie will give you an example that the 38 newly appointed agents in the first quarter. The majority of those agents are commercially focused, not to say that they can write personal lines and we would encourage them to do that as well. But the key is the new agents that we have appointed have the ability to write a diversified product lineup which is what we want.
And they also are the size that we know that we can grow with them long term. So these are agents that have to have certain mass to them so that as we continue to grow, we see that there’s some really longer-term opportunities with the agents that we have appointed. And those are very reflective of the current agency base.
So we have not really changed in terms of our appointment process for the agents but we do make sure that they are well vetted and we understand exactly what the prospects are in terms of future growth and the types of business that we want to be able to write with them.
Do you think the consolidation of the retail agency world is having much of an effect on you guys at the end of the day?
It’s not having a measurable effect on us, however it is something that we’re keenly aware of. We had spent a lot of time over the last two and three years particularly making sure that we forge relationships with some of them, the very larger banks if you will, as well some of the very, very large agencies that are going in and acquiring some of the smaller agencies.
Obviously, we have a book of business in some of those smaller agencies. One could view it and say that that book of business now becomes in play. And so we have strategically made sure that we are building the relationships with some of those very large banks and agency groups so that when that does occur that we’re in a position to continue to capitalize and protect that book of business that may be acquired. It has not had a real measured effect on us but it is something again that we’re keenly aware of.
Okay. Excellent. Thanks.
There are no further questions at this time.
We thank everyone for your participation in our conference call this morning. And we’ll talk to you again at the end of the second quarter.
Yes, thank you, everybody.
This concludes today’s conference call. You may now disconnect.
Copyright policy: All transcripts on this site are the copyright of Seeking Alpha. However, we view them as an important resource for bloggers and journalists, and are excited to contribute to the democratization of financial information on the Internet. (Until now investors have had to pay thousands of dollars in subscription fees for transcripts.) So our reproduction policy is as follows: You may quote up to 400 words of any transcript on the condition that you attribute the transcript to Seeking Alpha and either link to the original transcript or to www.SeekingAlpha.com. All other use is prohibited.
THE INFORMATION CONTAINED HERE IS A TEXTUAL REPRESENTATION OF THE APPLICABLE COMPANY’S CONFERENCE CALL, CONFERENCE PRESENTATION OR OTHER AUDIO PRESENTATION, AND WHILE EFFORTS ARE MADE TO PROVIDE AN ACCURATE TRANSCRIPTION, THERE MAY BE MATERIAL ERRORS, OMISSIONS, OR INACCURACIES IN THE REPORTING OF THE SUBSTANCE OF THE AUDIO PRESENTATIONS. IN NO WAY DOES SEEKING ALPHA ASSUME ANY RESPONSIBILITY FOR ANY INVESTMENT OR OTHER DECISIONS MADE BASED UPON THE INFORMATION PROVIDED ON THIS WEB SITE OR IN ANY TRANSCRIPT. USERS ARE ADVISED TO REVIEW THE APPLICABLE COMPANY’S AUDIO PRESENTATION ITSELF AND THE APPLICABLE COMPANY’S SEC FILINGS BEFORE MAKING ANY INVESTMENT OR OTHER DECISIONS.
If you have any additional questions about our online transcripts, please contact us at: email@example.com. Thank you!